What do you consider overrated by the underground ?

Recommendations, discussions, questions & debates regarding the godly Metal of olde...
Fucking Åmål
Posts: 1373
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 11:46 pm
Location: Lamia,Greece

Post by Fucking Åmål »

The only gay as far as the music choises,is that to follow like sheeps,what someone tries to persuade us.I am glad people follow their tastes and not hear everything one says.Before some time i said in the Miskatonic that i hate MOTORHEAD or love METAL ARCHIVES and look what 35 year old guys boring as hell told about me.Is this right to abuse in that way because he don't likes a band that is ''in'' for the TRUE METAL CIRCLES.We have thank god democracy,don't we?Everything you say in the MISK and don't like this that (more than 1000 posts :lol: )guys that consist a clique is considered blasphemy and they abuse you without reason.Is this right stance for normal,easy-going people?I think the onlyone that supported me(well with his own way...)was Dan which said things as they are.

CIRITH UNGOL-Strangely enough Cirith Ungol was one of my first bands from Metal to hear even before i got to heared Judas Priest!!! :shock: Cirith Ungol was always one of my fave bands,i liked all about them simply that!
User avatar
The Sentinel
Posts: 3527
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 2:32 pm
Location: Netherlands

Post by The Sentinel »

When I hear Cirith Ungol's "Master of the pit" I sometime thinks this is the best song ever recorded by humans, Cirith Ungol can do no wrong imo

I also like Slough Feg a lot. I consider Twilight of the idols as one of the best albums released beyond the 80's, really perfect stuff for me.
Long Live The Loud !!!
User avatar
ION BRITTON
Posts: 6645
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 3:07 pm

Post by ION BRITTON »

Fucking Åmål wrote:Before some time i said in the Miskatonic that i hate MOTORHEAD or love METAL ARCHIVES and look what 35 year old guys boring as hell told about me.Is this right to abuse in that way because he don't likes a band that is ''in'' for the TRUE METAL CIRCLES.We have thank god democracy,don't we?Everything you say in the MISK and don't like this that (more than 1000 posts :lol: )guys that consist a clique is considered blasphemy and they abuse you without reason.
What did they tell you? What do you mean by the word ''abuse''?
Good against Evil, Evil sure to win

"It really didn't matter if they liked it or not, i was going to give it to them straight down their throats" -John Stewart
Fucking Åmål
Posts: 1373
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 11:46 pm
Location: Lamia,Greece

Post by Fucking Åmål »

ION BRITTON wrote: What did they tell you? What do you mean by the word ''abuse''?
Hey nothing special,just joked disagreeing but i don't find always their jokes entertaining.Strangely enough the Metal Archives in the Slaughtered Lamb thread of MISK had vanished(?!) what happened?Some people take it for granted that we must be MOTORHEAD fans,are they on the other hand fans of GRAVESTONE,TYRANT,STORMWITCH,MANIAC,STORMWAVE?No :roll: Then please leave us to hear these unpopular bands and stik to the masses! :evil: :wink:
User avatar
mordred
Posts: 1792
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 2:44 pm
Location: Sweden

Post by mordred »

Stop it. About every truly amazing band there were in the forgotten underground metal scene of the 80's has been mentioned.

GOTHAM CITY, ZONE ZERO, TYRANT, CIRITH UNGOL = Masters of metal, and Agents of Steel alike. Period. Case closed.
Chroming Rose “Pressure” LP found! :D
boris
Posts: 227
Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 8:09 pm
Location: Israel

Post by boris »

mordred wrote:Stop it. About every truly amazing band there were in the forgotten underground metal scene of the 80's has been mentioned.

GOTHAM CITY, ZONE ZERO, TYRANT, CIRITH UNGOL = Masters of metal, and Agents of Steel alike. Period. Case closed.
"Every band" is quite harsh don't you think ? all mentioned except CU suck in my opinion (and no, it's not 'period, case closed'). There are plenty more that were very much great bands like Hell, Manilla Road, Tyrant's Reighn, Black Hole, Mistreater, Graven Image, Killen, Apocalypse / Omega, Desolation Angels etc.
FenderMedium

Post by FenderMedium »

None of these bands are talked about extensively enough to be considered "overrated" even in the underground, as much as I love obscure stuff I can see why alot of bands are obscure because they were subpar.
User avatar
OmenOfSteel
Posts: 577
Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006 4:03 pm
Location: fucking non white worthless left wing dick sucking scum bag

Re: What do you consider overrated by the underground ?

Post by OmenOfSteel »

Just commenting on the two most shocking picks you made :wink: :
Boris wrote:Tyrant (Hold back the Lightning) - they are just mediocre or below. The vocals are beyond annoying and the songs are just not interesting. It may cost around 200 - 300 euros, but it still sucks. The only good thing on this one are the first seconds of the b-side.
ARRGH! Blasphemy! I just recently heard this for the first time, and it totally and completely crushes! Perfect and one of the best NwobHM I ever heard!
Lord Weird Slough Feg - Can't understand the fuss about this one. Propagandized as the most true metal band ever, that would never sell out and will keep the metal spirit going and whatever else. OK, but their music's boring and annoyingly weird. I don't like it and don't understand it.
ARRRRGHHHH!!!
Probably best "new" band beyond the 80ies! Their irish/celtic influence is unique and brilliant as are the vocals!! Best album TWILIGHT OF THE IDOLS, best track is from debut THE RED BRANCH!!
Also fantastic: HAMMERS OF MISFORTUNE's debut (w/Mike Scalzi)
We praise the blood that metal brings
User avatar
mordred
Posts: 1792
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 2:44 pm
Location: Sweden

Post by mordred »

Boris wrote:"Every band" is quite harsh don't you think ? all mentioned except CU suck in my opinion (and no, it's not 'period, case closed'). There are plenty more that were very much great bands like Hell, Manilla Road, Tyrant's Reighn, Black Hole, Mistreater, Graven Image, Killen, Apocalypse / Omega, Desolation Angels etc.
Well, it's only that, besides Manilla Road, none of those bands can hold a candle to Gotham City, Zone Zero or Tyrant. Reality is harsh. Period. Case closed.
Chroming Rose “Pressure” LP found! :D
Fucking Åmål
Posts: 1373
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 11:46 pm
Location: Lamia,Greece

Post by Fucking Åmål »

Let's talk about the Swedish scene.Although tons of great bands there are some bands overrated by some known persons... :wink:I don't believe some people considering these bands as three of the top 5 swedish metal.

I still believe that AXEWITCH should stayed in demo.This band's releases are some of the most average bands of the swedish 80's.Can't believe why they rereleased 4 full-lengths albums and high-vaultage released all of them.They were tons of other swedish bands for official rereleases.

ZONE ZERO still is overrated.Why do you think it is one of the best Swe-acts?


CRYSTAL PRIDE-same 81.It is very good musically but the vocals destroy it(very thin-female vocals,irritating some times).A man behind the microphone would made it a masterpiece.


That some examples i would liked to refered to.
User avatar
DaN
Administructor
Posts: 7369
Joined: Thu Jun 15, 2006 9:19 am
Location: Stockholm Metal Underground
Contact:

Post by DaN »

Bringing up everyone's "favourite" subject AND slagging some classic Swedish Metal in the process - this will hardly win you the poplularity vote around here :lol:

Seriously though, I do think there's plenty of Swedish bands that are overrated in the sense that they get namedropped far too often than their actual music deserves, but ZONE ZERO and early CRYSTAL PRIDE are not included. Sussie's vocals might not be that special, but I can't see how they would ruin the music in any way.

Long, impopular list of Swedish acts to be thrashed soon..
User avatar
sovdat
Posts: 2621
Joined: Sat Feb 03, 2007 9:52 pm
Location: Slovenia
Contact:

Post by sovdat »

Perhaps ... Slauter Xstroyes?? Well, I'll have to give it some more spins, the first riff is an absolute killer, but as I remember the "No Idea" was extremely gay?! Here, it's on, so I'll have to wait and see :)

(I didn't know the existance of the band until I ran into a discussion with a well-known joker from Slovenian scene about the thrash scene, and he brought up Slauter Xstroyes and talked about them as a thrash band ... so it was a very unpleasant surprise at first :) )
User avatar
Keir
Posts: 1249
Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:16 pm
Location: Massachusetts, USA
Contact:

Post by Keir »

Add me to the list of people who find Slough Feg to be overrated. Not bad at all but I much prefer Scalzi’s other band, Hammers of Misfortune. I heard HoM first and immediately wanted to hear what Slough Feg was like, but I was disappointed. So that’s where I’m coming from.

As for Zone Zero and Crystal Pride, can you really call them overrated? I haven’t heard that many people raving about them.
User avatar
Helm
Posts: 1465
Joined: Tue Jun 26, 2007 2:28 pm
Location: Beyond the Realms of Arcana!

Post by Helm »

I really didn't think ARC were all that! Not bad, but nothing great. I adore Cirith Ungol. I find Lord Weird okay for a few songs, a lot of their material misses with me. The Brocas Helm connection is overplayed. Brocas Helm have not recorded a bad song in their period as a band imo, the same cannot be said about Slough Feg.
Image
User avatar
mordred
Posts: 1792
Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2006 2:44 pm
Location: Sweden

Post by mordred »

Please don't give me more of this... ZONE ZERO are simply gods. Divine. Greater than life itself. As for AXEWITCH I can see why someone does not get all aroused by them... But as far as I am concerned, out of LP-bands of Sweden, only GOTHAM CITY and perhaps MERCY and HEAVY LOAD were better.

SLOUGH FEG rules. Rarely have I heard such a tasteful, original take on classic metal during the last decade. For sure one of the best new bands in later years, although it's been 11 years since their first album now. As far as I'm concerned they are much better than BROCAS HELM.
Chroming Rose “Pressure” LP found! :D
Post Reply