Avenger, you have a point here, but as I told you, nothing is either black or white. When I entered the TMAG forum (Feb 2010), I was too bored (or too gay according to Doomedplanet

) to learn all the rules and the procedure about ripping and uploading, so I thought it was fair to pay in order to receive the priviliges other guys had, due to their personal contribution. After a while, I didn't like being passive and as I felt member of the community, (despite i wasn't obligated anymore) I started uploading MY RIPS from MY PERSONAL COLLECTION, or stuff that my friends ripped from their collection. I thought it was degrading and indignified to use other guys rips for mine, from other sites. I think that the majority of the uploads there, came from TMAG's members own sources as well. You must admit that this percentage (>50%) was way higher than any other similar site or forum.
As a conclusion, I think its too hard to define clearly and strictly the ethics of uploading music, because it's something illegal (=unethical??) from the beginning.
PS. The new stuff uploads were already banned when I entered. So we are talking mainly about OOP uploads that hardly harm the band. On the contrary, many times the spreading of the music (illegally) was the reason of the creation of a fan base, that led later to a legitimate reissue. But that's another talk.
We should forgive our enemies, but not before they are hanged...